WTF! why is VIA BTC still mining segwit coin. - reddit.com

M-N 1k-5k

m0xyy M0Zark M14Gang M1Finance M1Rifles M2Kgifs M59Gar m83 MAA MAABMakeup Mac4491 macarons Macau macbookair macedonia macgyver MacGyverThis Machine_Embroidery MachineGunKelly MachineLearningJobs MachineLuck machinesbeingjerks MachineThatMakesMoney machinima machiningporn MachoManGIFs MackenzieFoy Macklemore macmini MacNCheesePorn MacOSBeta macpro macprogramming macrame macro macroeconomics macrophotography macross MacUni MadamSecretary MadDabs Madden18 Madden19 maddenmobilebuysell MaddenMobileH2H maddiegiannamore MaddieReed MaddieZiegler madeinusa MadeleineMccann MadeMeGiggle mademehappycry madewithableton madeWithGodot MadFurs MadisonGordon MadisonLouch MadisonPettis MadisonWIPokemonGo MadiTeeuws MadLabs madladcrusaders madlass madlasses Madlib MadMaxGame Madoka Madonna MadOver30 madscientist MafiaCityMemes MAFS_TV MAGAjuana Magento Magfest MaggieGrace MaggieQ magiarecord MagicalGirls magicalmoments MagicaVoxel MagicCardPulls magicfart69 magicgathering Magicite MagicItems magicka MagicLantern magicmuggle MagicMushroomHunters MagicMushrooms magicplantsexchange magicrush magictricksrevealed MagicUsers magikarpusedflylol Magisk Magleby magnora7 MAguns Mahayana Mahjong Mahryahh mahvelmods MaiaMitchell maidsafe maille mainebeer MaineCoon mainehistory mainframe maisie_williams MaitlandWardBaxter majorasmask MajorLazer Maka91Productions makeaband makecomics MakeDataShine MakeDejiLaugh MakeFriends MakeFriendsInGermany MakeFriendsInIndia MakeItFunnyIAMA MakeItWorse Makemeagif makemecry MakeMeSmile makemkv MakeMoney MakeMoneyOnlineGuide makenoise MakEnts makerbot MakerMesh makerspace MakeStories MakeSushi MakeTotalDestr0i Makeup_Artists Makeup_Reviews MakeupAddictionAsia makeupeffects MakeUpExchangeEU makeupfails MakeupMemes MakeupNews MakeupReviews MakeupSelfies MakeupTutorials MakeWay makingmoney MakingRnB Makingsense malamute MalaysianPF Male_Feet Male_Lesbians maleempowerment malefashionuk MaleFemme malefoodadvice MaleMidriff MaleStudies MaleSupportNetwork maletime MaliciousStupidity Malifaux MalinAkerman malingering malkovich mallninja Mallsoft MalluBabes Malmoe malphitemains malta Maltese Malwarebytes MalzaharMains MamaRaikou ManagedByNarcissists managementconsulting Manatees manbuns manchester_uni Manchester_United Manchestercity ManchesterNH manchesterorchestra manchesterunitednews MandachordMelodies Mandala mandalas Mandalorian Mandela_Effect_Music MandJTV mAndroidDev mandymilano mandymoore MandyRose mangadex MangaMemes MangaPod mangarockapp mangastudio mangaswap ManHands manhattan ManifestEarth Manitoba Mankato Manna MannausSachsen manoman manseekingwoman mansformation ManyBaggers MaoGame MaokaiMains mapgore mapprojects mapswith2newzealands MapsWithoutEurope MapsWithoutHawaii mapswithouticeland mapswithoutmadagascar MapsWithoutMaps MapsWithoutTasmania MapsWithoutUP mapswithtoomuchNZ MapVsGeo Marathon Marathon_Training marathonrunning marathons marblerun MarchAgainstNazis Marching_Arts marchmadness MarciLLy MarcMaron MarcoPolo Mari_Bambei MariaDomark MariaDoroshina MariahCarey MariaMenounos mariasharapova MariaSolPerez MariaVillalba MarieAnnWatson MarieAvgeropoulos MarieDoll Marieism MarieMadore Marietta Mariiiagad Marijuana_Stocks marijuanaconcentrates marijuanalabs MarilynMonroe Marimba Marin MarinaAndTheDiamonds MarinaLaswick marinelife marines marioandluigi MarioKart8Deluxe MarioKartWii marioncotillard MARIOPARTY mariorabbids marisamiller maritime Marixa Market_Socialism MarketAnarchism MarketingAutomation marketingnews MarketingPorn MarketingResearch Markham MarksmanMains Marquette marriageadvice marriagefree marriageisbliss MarriageMemes MarriedLife marriedwithchildren MarsArgo marshmello MarsSociety marthahunt MarthMains MartialArtsWeapons martinfreeman Martingarrix MartinShkreli MarvelatFox MarvelAvengersProject MarvelBattleLines MARVELFutureFight marvelleaks MarvelPosters Marvels_Luke_Cage MarvelStudiosTheories MarvelTheories marveltsumtsum marvelvscapcom marxistreadingclub MaryBaltazar MarylandPolitics MarziaSubmissions MasamuneKunNoRevenge masari Masastan MaschinenKrieger masculism mashgifs Masks MasonJars MassachusettsPolitics massagetherapy masseffectfics masseffectlore MassEffectmeme MassEffectMemes massivecocks masskillers MassQuantities masstagger MasterchefAU MasterclassDropship mastercoin MasterGardener MastermindBooks MasterNodes masteroforion masters MastersOfSex MastersOfTheUniverse MasterSystem MasterYiMains Mastodon mastodonband masturbationhacks masturbationquestions Masub MatchedBettingUK MatebookXPro math_irl Mathcore Mathematica mathporn mathpsych mathpuzzles MatiWrites matrix matt01ss MattAndKim mattayahu MattLees MattParker Mattress MattRichardsen MattShea mattsmith MattsWrittenWord MatureBeauty matureplants mau5trap Maude_Garrett MauraMurrayCase MauraMurrayEvidence mauritius mavic MavicPro MaximilianDood MaxLandis Maxmoefoe maxpayne Maya_Preffered MayansMC MaybeHappened MaydayPAC mazda6 mazdaspeed3 MazeRunner mazes mbta MBTIDating mbtimemes MbtiTypeMe mc5 MCAT2 MCBuildSchool Mccafferty MCCEO McCreeMains McDonaldsEmployees mcdonaldsfreakout McElroyClan McJuggerNuggets McKennaBerkley mckennademoe McKinney mclaren McLounge McMansionHell mcmodfinder mcrealmsservers mcsa MCSPlaystation MCSRep MCSXbox mctourney mculeaks MCUmemes MCVanillaServers MDbeer MDEnts MDGuns mdmazingMusic mdphd MDT me__irl me_atm me_ftl me_InRocketLeague me_irl_neue me_irl_video mealprepsundays MEandromeda MeanGirls meanstack MeansTV meanwhileinrussia meateatertv meatheads meatogains mechanic MechanicalEngineer mechanicalgifs MechanicalKeyboardsUK mechanicalpuzzles mechatronics mechwarrior med_diet Medford mediacomposing MedianXL mediaquotes MediBloc medical_advice medical_news Medical_Students MedicalAssistant MedicalBulletin MedicalDevices medicalimages MedicalMeme MedicalPhysics medicalporn medicalschooluk MedicareForAll medicinehat medieval medievalcatpaintings MedievalEngineers medievalMemes MedievalMusic MedievalNorseStudies MedievalPorn medievalworldproblems meditation_videos meditationpapers meditationpics MeditationPractice mediterraneandiet mediumfaketexts mediumformat Mediums MedSpouse MedTech MeeseeksAndDestroy MeetLGBT MegaAnime megabots Megadrive MegaGames Megahosting MEGAlink megalinks2 MegalinksVault MegaloBox MegaMakerOfficial megamindmemes MegaMusic megarequests MegaVideos MeghanMarkle meghanmccarthy MegTurney3 megumikoneko mehfaketexts MeiMains MEIOUandTaxes Meirl_ meirlcirclejerk MekaMechanic MelancholyMusic MelanieLaurent MelanieMartinez MelaniePavola MelanieShark MelbEnts melbournecirclejerk melbournemusic MelbournePhotography melbourneriders MelbTrade Melee MelissaDrew MelissaSandoval melodica melodicmetal melonproject meltyblood meme_hell meme_history meme_irl Meme_LOL meme_lords memecalendar MemeChildren MemeDerWoche Memedetails MemeEconomyEconomy memefood MemeFormats MemeGang MemeInvestor_bot Memelee memes_irl memesbannedinchina MemesBrasil memesec MemesForDayz MemeSmiet MemesOfAnime memesofthedank MemesPortugal MemeStockMarket memeswithoutmods Memeulous memeuniverse MemeVideos memewarsnews memorization memoryforensics MemoryQuestions MemphisExpress memphisrap memrise men MENAConflicts menameselassie MenaPay MenDatingTips menfashion MenGetRapedToo Menieres meninblazers menlaughingwithsalad menofwar Menopause mensa mensfashiontrend menshealth Mensmittenwithkittens MensOnlineStylist MensRants menstruation menswear Mentalfloss MentalHealthPH MentalHealthProviders MentalHealthSupport mentalmath mentalpod mentat MenuHacker MephHeads Mercadoreddit Mercari mercedes mercedesamgf1 Mercerinfo MerchantRPG MerchByAmazon merchents MercuryProtocol MercWithAMouth MeredithMickelson merlinbbc mermaids MerrellTwins merval mescaline Mescamushroom MESG Meshnet Meshuggah mesoamerica messi messingwiththenewguy meta meta_me_irl metaboardgames metabowsette MetaBuffGames MetaHub Metal101 MetalCasting MetalDrums metalearth Metalfoundry MetalGearAntiNuclear MetalGearPhilanthropy MetalGearSolidV_PC metalgearsurvive MetalicKitten_ Metallize metallurgy Metalmusic MetalNews MetalPay MetalPlaylists MetalSlugAttack metalwallpapers metametacirclejerk metaphysical MetaPhysicalMemes metaquebec metasploit MetaSubredditDrama MetaTrueReddit Metaverse_Blockchain Meteor Methadone meToo Metric metricband MetricMasterRace metro_exodus MetroDetroit metroexodus Metrology MetronomeToken MetroPCS mets mewithoutYou MexicanSpaceProgram Mexico_News mexicocirclejerk mexicogonewild Mezcal MFA mfa_irl MFGhost mflbguide MFZ MGSPhantomPain mgtowbooks mh4u MHGen MHGU mhguildquests mhmixedsets MHOC MHOnline MHWorld miakhalifapics MiaLi MiaMalkovaX miamiheat MiamiHurricanes miamioh MiaSand MiBox Michael MichaelFassbender MichaelReeves MichaelScottPapCo MichaelSneakers Michele_Maturo MichelleKeegan michellelewin MichelleRodriguez Michigan4Sanders michigandate MichiganGamers MicrobrandWatches microbrute microcomputing Microfiber MicroFishing microgreens microkitty Micromanufacturing micronations microphones microservices MicrosoftBand MicrosoftFlow MicrosoftServices MicrosoftTeams microtonal Midair midcentury Middleearthmemes MiddleEast MiddleEasternMusic MiddleEastHistory MideastPeace MidEastRegionalWar Midessa midi midlyinfuriating midlyinteresting midori midquelmemes Midwives MieshaTate mightyboosh MightyHarvest MightyNo9 Mignolaverse migos Miguns Miitopia Mike MikeAndIke MikePatton milano milasantos_ MiLB mildhighclub mildly_penis mildlyannoying mildlyapocalyptic mildlyawesome mildlyboobs mildlybutthole Mildlyclever mildlyconfusing mildlydangerous mildlyenteristing mildlyevangelion mildlyfrustrating MildlyGIT mildlyhalo mildlyhitler mildlyhomestuck mildlyinconvenient mildlyinsulted mildlyinterestingIAmA mildlyintersting mildlyintimidating mildlyintresting MildlyMetal mildlypleasing MildlyRacist mildlyretarded mildlyridiculous mildlysketchy MildlyUncomfortable mildlyuninteresting mildlyunsettling MildlyVandalized mildlyweird mildlywtf mildypenis MileyCyrusNTF MilfQueenMirelia milfsgonewild milfslovecumshots MILFVideo Milim militant Militariacollecting MilitaryARClones MilitaryAviation MilitaryConspiracy militaryfitness MilitaryGear Militarymachines MilitaryProcurement Militaryraging MilitaryStrategy milkniggas millajovovich millenials Millennials MillerPlanetside MillieBobbyBrown2 MillionDollarsBut millwrights milsurp miltonkeynes MilwaukeeTool Mimblewimble mimovi mina_irl Minarchy MindBleach mindblown mindcrackcirclejerk MindcrackDiscussion Mindfuck mindfuleating Mindscan mindstorms MinecraftCirclejerk MinecraftCommands MinecraftCringe minecraftcursedimages MinecraftDataMining minecraftfaq MinecraftHistory minecraftmaps MinecraftMod MinecraftPE minecraftschematics minecraftskins MinecraftSwitch MinecraftToDo minecraftwaterniggas minecraftxbox MinedBlock Minerals minerapocalypse MinersHaven MinerSwap Minesweeper Minetest MineZ Mini14 mini_trucks miniature_calendar MiniaturePinscher MiniatureSchnauzer miniaturesculpting miniaussie minibikes minicooking MiniDayZ minidocs minimal_homes minimalism_fashion minimalism_music Minimalisticmemes minimalisticwalls minimaltechno MiniMetro MiningPoolHub MinionMasters MinionMemes Minions MinkaKelly minnesotabeer MinnesotaCamping MinnesotaGamers Minnesotar4r minorkey MintCoin mintmobile mintsim MinusTheBear MinusTheMakeup minutevids MIOAGTIRPAAP MioFanClub Miracleofsound miraclerobots mirainikki mirin MirrorlessPhotography MirrorSports misbakes Miscarriage mischiefvixen Misdirection mises mishacollins MisheardLyrics MisleadingCaptions MisleadingTitles MissedOpportunity MissEm_Emily MissFlowerBomb MissFortuneMains MissGenii MissileGfys MissilePorn Missing_Person Mission_Impossible MissionWorkshop missoula MissouriPolitics MisterMetokur MitchHedberg MithrilToken mitski MitsubishiEvolution miui mixcd MixClub mixednuts mixedreality mizzou MK11CharacterTowers MKUltra MLB_9Innings mlb_streams MLBDraft MLBtheShowLogos mlclass MLG MLjobs MLM mlmcirclejerk MLMRecovery mlmscams mlmstories MLP MLPAnalysis MLPIOS mlpmature MLPtunes MLRugby MLSAwayFans MLSstreams MLTP mmapredictions MMAstream MMAStreams365 mmatechnique mmaww MMElementalGuardians mmf mmt_economics Mnemonics MNFgifs MNJobs MNN_MemeNewsNetwork MNTrolls moab moai moana MoarStories Mobdro Mobile_Marketing MobileAL mobileDJ MobileGames MobileLegendsBB mobilepicshd MobileUI mobilewebdev mobilinkcoin MobiusNetwork MockTheAltRight mocktheweek modclub ModdedMC moddergearsolid moddingguides ModdingMC ModdingMorrowind Model3 MODELING modelrailroads moderatelyinteresting ModerationLog modernart modernbaseball moderncalligraphy ModernFashionPorn modernism ModernistCuisine ModernJazz ModernJund ModernPropaganda ModernRockMusic modernrogue ModernWarfareRM Modesto ModFighters modgifs modlimit ModMurder ModsAreKillingReddit modusoperandi Moebius moedred MoeStash MoiraMains Moissanite moldova molecularbiology MolecularGastronomy MoleIsMoney Moles moleskine Molested molly Molly_Eskam MollyB MollyCQuinn MollyEskamNew mollyeskamshit Mom mombloggers momenttheymadeit momjokes MommaJokes momo Momoland MomoTama MomPorn momreflexes momsspaghetti monacoin MonarchsFactory Monarkia Monash moncton mondegreens Mondo MoneroCommunity moneromarket moneromarkets MoneroV Monetha MoneyHelp moneylaundering moneyontheside moneyrebel MoneyToken mongolia MongoliaPics MonicaBellucci monicoin MonikasThighs Monikers MonitorLizards Monk MonkeyIsland MonkeypawProductions monkeys monodatingpoly monogame monogatari MonoHearing MonolidMakeup monopoly Monsanto MonstaX Monstera monsterdeconstruction monsterdongs monsterfactory MonsterFishKeepers monsterfuzz MonsterGirlRP MonsterHigh MonsterLegends monsteroftheweek MonsterProm MonsterStrike Montageparodybattles montenegro MontereyBay Monterrey Montessori montgomery MonthlyComposition MontrealCycling MontrealEnts montrealimpact montrealjobs montypythongifs monzo moo_irl moog moombahton Moomies Moomins moomooio moon MoonCoin moonero MoonFucks MoonKnight Moonlighter MOONMOON_OW MoonriseMusicFestival Moons_IRL moosearchive moraldilemmas MoralPanic Morbid morbid_reality MordhauFashion mordheim morebreedingdittos Morel_Hunting MorganaMains MorgantownWV mormoncringe Mormonleaks mormonpolitics MorningDrawfee Morninghair MoroccoPics MoronicMondayAndroid MorpheusNetwork MorphRequests morrissey morse MortalEngines MortalKombat11 MortalKombatX morticians MortisGang Mosaic Moscow Mosses mostgilded MostInterestingCats MostlyWrites motherinlawsfromhell mothersbasement Mothman mothpit Motionografree MotivatedMusic motivateme Motivation_Wallpapers Motivational MotleyCrue motleyfool moto motog5 MotoGPPorn MotoGuzzi MotoLA Motoracing motorbikes motorboat Motorcyclecrash motorizedbicycles motorola Motorsport MotorsportPorn MotorsportsCalendar motorsportstreams motoswap Motovlogging motown MotoX4 MountainBike mountaindew mountaineers mountaingoats MountainMen Mountainpics mountains mountainview MountAndBall MouseGifs MouseGuard MouseMarket MousepadReview MouthEyes movember MovementDAO MovementDEMF Movie_Mistakes movie_scores movieaweek MovieBattles2 moviecirclejerk MovieHDLite movieideas movieleaks moviemonsterporn MovieOfTheDay MovieQuotes moviereviews MovieRls MoviesAnywhere MovieScandals Movieswhilehigh moving movingout mowerthoughts Mowky Mozart MozartInTheJungle mozilla MozillaInAction MP5 mpcusers mpmb mpminidelta MrBeast MrData MRE MrJoeNobody mrmoneymustache MrNightmare MrPedestrian mrpickles MrRobotARG MrRogersNeighborhood MrsGlass1024 MrSuicideSheep MSAccess msaeachubaets MsGinaDarling MSI MSP430 mspaintsartrace mspjobs MSsEcReTPoDcAsT Msstate MTBDeals MTBGE MTBTrailBuilding MTBVideos MtFHRT mtg_altered mtg_dadjokes MTGArenaPro mtgbracket mtgbrawl MTGDredge mtgfrontier mtgGore MTGLardFetcher mtglimited mtgmarketwatch MTGmemes MTGModern mtgoxinsolvency MTGPuzzleQuest mtgspirits mtgstorm mtgtrades MTGVintage MTHFR MtPelerin MTSU MTU mua muacjcirclejerk MUAEurope mudfossils Mueller mufc_history mugen mugi_irl muji Mujico mukbang Muks_store MuLegend multiculturalcancer multilingualparenting MultiMemeDrifting multireddit mumfordandsons MumkeysAnimeReviews MUN munchies MunchkinCats munichsocialclub murder MurderByWords MurderedByAntivaxx MurderedByBots MurderedByCrosspost murderedbyemojis MurderedByFacts murderedbymemes murderedbynumbers MurderedByOuija MurderedByPedantics murderedbyscreenshots Murderinos MurderMountain MurderMystery2 murfreesboro murmuration muscle_cars musclecarporn musclegirlart MuscleWorship muselk MuseumPorn museumreviews Museums Mushishi mushroom Mushroom_Cultivation music_discovery Music_Producers Music_Theory_Class MusicaEnEspanol MusicAlbums musicalcomedy musicalscripts MusicalTears MusicalTheatre Musicandmathematics musicanova musicbee musicbusiness MusicCirclejerk musiceducation MusicElectronics MusicEssentials Musicforyourfilm MusicFromTVSeries MusicGear musicgifstation MusicGuides musichistory musichoarder musiciansblogs musicindustry musicinstructor musiclessmusicvideos musicmadefree musicmakers musicmarketing MusicMatch MusicNotes musicoin musicpics MusicProducerSpot MusicProductionCodex MusicProductionDeals musicprogramming MusicPromotion musicsoftwaredeals musicsuggestions musictherapy MusicVideosOnYouTube musicwallpapers musiquefrancaise MuskDidNothingWrong Muslim Muslim_Memes MuslimLounge MuslimMarriage MustangTech mustelids mutantsandmasterminds MutantYearZeroRTE MUTCoinSelling mutt MUTTalk mutualcollaboration mutualfunds mutualism MutualSupport MVIS mvsw MWLL mx5 MXC MXStreams myaimistrue MyAnimeList myanmar MyBigFatFabulousLife MyBloodyValentine mybullytoday MyCastleFE MycoBazaar Mycoporn Mydaily3 MyDoggyIsMyLove mydrunkkitchen MyEtherWallet myfaithcoin mygamecollection_app MyHatIsACat MyHeroAcademiaMemes Myhush MylifeSuxNow mylittlealcoholic mylittleandysonic1 mylittleconspiracy mylittledamon mylittledaww mylittlefanfic mylittlefortress mylittlehuman mylittlelistentothis Mylittlenosleep mylittleonions MyLittleOutOfContext MyLittleSquidward MyLittleSupportGroup mymatematt mymorningjacket MyNameIsEarl myNBA2KMobile MyNewFetish MyNoise MyouiMina myparentsarenthome MyPrettyFace myriadcoin MyrtleBeach MySingingMonsters myst Mysteries mysterysearch mysticism myterribleneighbors myth MyTheoryIs myvegas

n00bs n3rdfusion N64WrestlingGames naath Nachrichten Nadine_Leopold NadineKerastas nagios nahuatl nail_art nailbiting nailedthelanding Nailpolish NaiTech nakedandafraid nameaserver Namecoin NameMyTF2Item NameNerdCirclejerk NamePuns namethatbook NamiMains Nanachi nanaimo nandovmovies nanJ Nannies nano NanoGrowery Nanoleaf nanomusheens nanotechnology Nantes NaomiKyle NaomiScott naomiwatts napa Naperville NapkinMemes Naples_FL napoli naranon narcissisticparents NarcissisticSpouses NarcoticsAnonymous Narduchita NarFFL Narnia NarniaMemes Naruto_Memes NarutoAkiden NarutoAnime NarutoNinjaStorm NarutoSakuga NarutoXBorutoNV nas NASA_News nasalsnuff NASCARCollectors NasDANQ nashvillebuyandsell Nashvilleevents NashvilleJobs NashvilleSC NashvilleTV NASLSoccer nasusmains Nat1 Natalia_Deliah Natalia_Garibotto Natalie_vs_Scarlett nataliebrooksx nataliehadek NatalieMariduena NatalieR NatalieRoser NatashaOakley nathanfielder NathanFillion Nationalism NationalParkPorn NationalPhotoSubs nationalsomethingday NationStates NativeAmericanGirls NativeAmericans NativeInstruments nativescript natsuki Natsuri NattyComics Natural_Hair NaturalPregnancy naturalremedies NaturalWellnessGuide naturebros natureisbeautiful NatureIsFuckingCute Natureisfuckingnope natureislit natureismental naturesfury NAU Naughty_Redheads naughtydog naughtyjessthoughts NaughtyNerdGirls NaughtyNorseMemes naut Nautical NauticusBlockchain NautilusMains nav Navajo NavalAction Navia Naviaddress Navixsport NavyNukes NayaRivera nayeon Nazer_The_Lazer NaziMeme nba2k17 NBA2K19 NBA2KL NBA2kMTselling nba_live_streams NBAanalytics nbabreakdown nbafiftyfifty NBAGIFS NBAimages nbakicks NBALive_Mobile nbalivestreamshd NBAlounge NBApeopleTwitter NBAPlaygrounds nbastreams_ nbastreamscss nbl nbn NCAA ncaa_stream ncaabowlgames ncaabowllive NCAAFootball NCAAW ncbeer NCGuns NCLEX ncpolitics NCTrails NDE ndp NDQ nds NDSHacks nealstephenson NearDeathExperiences NeatMike NeatNotes NebulaPorn NECA neckbeards neckbeardthings neckdeep necromancers Necrontyr necropolis nederlands nedforpresident NeebsGaming Need NeedABand needabro needacoach NeedleInAHaystack Needlepoint NeedsMoreJPEG NeesyRizzo NegaRedditRedux NegativeAtmosphere negativeutilitarians negotiation neighborsfromhell Neil_deGrasse_Tyson NeilBreen neildegrassetyson neilyoung NeivaMaraDaily NemiForest Nendoroid nenes Neo4j neoblockchain neoconNWO neofolk neogeo neology NeoMagazin NeonGenesisEvangelion neoprogs Neopsychedelia NeoScavenger Neoyokio NEPA NepalPics nerdbait nerdcity nerdcore nerdfitness nerdgirls nerdlass nerdpokerpodcast nerdshowerthoughts nerdwriter Nerdy_Hardbodies NerdyChallenge NerfExchange NerfTheGame neshamira NessMains net_neutrality netapp NetBSD netdef NetflixCanada NetflixKingdom NetflixSpaceForce NetflixTheSociety netflixuk NetherlandsPics Netherwing NetHunter netsec_news netsec_uncensored Netsphere Netsuite NetworkForSale NetworkSecurity Neuralink neurallace NeuralNetwork neurobiology Neurofeedback NeuroFunk Neuromation neuronaut Neuroneum neuroproducers Neurosurgery NeutralCryptoTalk NeutralTalk Nevada nevadapolitics neveragainmovement NeverStopAGirlFight NeverTrump neverwinternights New_Hampshire New_Jersey_Politics New_Tattoos New_World_MMO New_York_City NewAge NewAgeMusic NewAlbums NewAmsterdamTV Newark newborns Newbraunfels newbrunswickcanada NewBrunswickNJ Newbwriters NewChallenger NewCountry NewCydiaTweaks NewDads NewedgeMustang Newegg newengland NewEngland4Sanders NewEnglandPatriots newenglandrevolution neweracaps NewFishSpecies NewGame newgrass Newgrounds newhaven newhiphop newhorizons newIBM newico NewJerseyforSanders NewJerseyMarijuana newleaf newLegacyinc Newlyweds neworleanssaints NewPMDT NewPokimanePics newportbeach NewRetroArcade NewRiders News_Politics newsbotbot newsentences newsokunomoral newsokuvip newspapercomics newsrebooted newsreels newsubreddits NewToReddit NewWest newwords newworldorder NewYorkCoin NewYorkForSanders NewYoutubers NewZanada newzealand_travel Nexo Nexomon NexonDarknessRises Nexplanon NextCarGame nextdoor nextelderscrolls NextOrder Nexus10 Nexus9 nexusearth nexusmods Nexusography nexusplayer nexybit NFC NFCEast nffc NFKRZ NFL2go nfl__stream nfl__streams nfl_games nfl_live_streams_free nfl_livestream_ nfl_livestream_free nfl_streams_hd nfl_streams_live_ nfl_super_bowl NFLDRAFT NFLFandom NFLFantasy NFLFilms NFLFootballGamesToday nflgameslive NFLGameUpdate nfllivestream_ NFLLiveStreamingCBS NFLLiveStreamingFOX NFLNoobs NFLOffTopic NFLReplay nflsgame NFLstatheads nflstream_ nflstream_free nflstream_live nflstreams_ nflstreams_free nflstreams_live_ NFLStreamUpdate nflsuperbowlfree nflsuperbowls nfrealmusic nfrstream nginx NhiTran NHL17HUT NHL18 NHL19 nhl_streams NHLChampionshipBelt NHLstream NHRA nhs niagara NibbaTV Nicaragua niceb8m8 NiceCatch nicedoggos nicegays Nicegirlstories niceguy niceguysDiscussion niceguystories NiceLegs NiceSaveOuija niceyes NichameleonCosplay NichtDieTagespresse nick NickCave nickelodeon NickyWhelan nicolapeltz nicolascage NicoleArbour NicoleLZ NicoleMarieJeanNMJ NicoleMejia nicolenixon NicoleScherzinger NicoleThornedab niconiconi NICUParents NidaleeMains NiennaJade NieRAutomataGame Nievamara Nigahiga Nigeria nightblade nightdriving nightmare NightmareBeforeXmas NightmareNewYork Nightmares nightmemes NightMusic nightphotography nightwalk nightwish nihilisms nihongo Nijmegen NikaidouSaki nikkibella NikkiBlackketter NikkiCo65 Nilesy nim Nimiq nincirclejerk ninemuses Ninja Ninjago NinjasHyper ninjawarrior NinoNakano Nintendeals Nintendo3DS nintendo64 Nintendo_NX NintendoDS Nintendogs NintendoKaren nintendolabo NintendoStitch NintendoSwitchBoxArt NintendoSwitchDesigns NintendoSwitchIndie NinthWorldProblems nintype nippleshadows nipponichi NipseyHussle nirvannatheband nissanfrontier nissanleaf NISTControls NitroToken NIU NixOS NixPlatform NJ_Swingers njbeer NJGuns njhiking NJr4r NJTech nlpclass NLSS NLTP NMMNG NMS_Bases NMS_Federation NMS_Zoology NMSPortals NNNNNNNEEEEEEEEEEEEWS no No_Cry_Challenge No_Ragrets NoAdmins noagenda NoahCyrus noahelowyn NoahGetTheBoat noamchomsky NoAnimePolice nobackspace Noblesse NobodyCaresApostolate noclip NoColoreds NoCopyrightMusic nocopyrightsounds nocrychallenge nocturnemains NoDAPL nodered Nodis NoeliaRamirez NoelleFoley NoelLeon noelmiller nOfAileDPriNtS NoFapES NoFapTeens NoFapWarRebooted nofiller NoFilterNews nofriends nofx nogagreflex NOIA NoIAP NoIdeaAnimation noids noip noise noisefuck NoisyImages noisypics NOIZ nojibrilnolife Nokia7Plus NOLA NOLAMusic Nolan NoLawns NolibsWatch nolimitcoin NoLogsVpn NoLongerAlone Nomad nomagicsuckery NOMANSSKY NoMansSkyAnimals NoMansSkyCrafting NoMansSkyMyJourney NoMansSkyShips NoMansSkyTravelGuide NomSaying NonAustrianEconomics noncensored_bitcoin nonconformists NonCredibleDefense nondirective nonduality NonEnglishMusic nonessentialoils NoNetNeutrality nonfiction nonfiction_bookclub nonfictionbooks NonGold NONINEWS NonNudeButSexy nonon Nonononomaybe nonononono nonononowaitwhat nonononoyesWTF nonoyes Nonprofit_Jobs nonsenselocker nonstopknight NoNut19 Nonviolence noobmaster69 NoobsOfTheAncient Noobtube nook nootropic_deals NootropicResearch NoPee noplastic nopuns norcal Nordichistorymemes NordicSkinCare NordicUnion NORDVEI NormalDayInSweden normanok NormanReedus normiememes NORML Norsemen NorskFotball NorthAmerican northampton NorthCarolina4Sanders northcounty northshore Northwestern NoRules norwayonreddit NorwegianForestCats Norwich NorwichCity Noses nosgoth nosIeep nosleep_irl nosleepfinder NosleepIndex NoSleepInterviews NoSleepReruns NoSleepSleuths NoSleepVideos nosleepworkshops nOSplatform nosql nostalgiacritic NostalgiaMusic NoStepOnSnek Not_Quite_Right NotableUpcomingEvents NotAboutYou notaglobe notalodeon notalwaysright NotaMethAddict notanimemaru NoTap notaperfectfit NotBirdsWithArms Notchcels notcirclejerk notcosplaygirls note8 Notflix notfunny NothingButThieves nothingnowhere NotHowDicksWork nothowgayswork nothowphoneswork notificationgore NoTillGrowery NotionSo notkayfabenews notmeirl notopbutok notpopping notredamefootball notsafeforweiss NotSteveIrwin notthebabylonbee notthebeaverton notthethickofit NotTrending notwholesomeanymore NoU novajobs novalaunchersetups novarent novationcircuit NoveltyAccounts Nowhere_eternity nowhisper nowiknow nowontennis noxappplayer NPB NPC NPCMemes NPCtavern NPD NPERproject npm nprplanetmoney NPSL nqmod Nr2003 nra nsa NSCollectors nsfNSFW NSFW911 nsfw_brat NSFW_SplitDepthGIFS nsfwbabesnude NSFWfun Nsfwhumour nspire nsw nswf NSWF_amatuer NSWFHardcore ntbdbiwdfta ntnu NTSB_database NTU NuclearBusiness nuclearwar nuclearweapons Nudah NudeBase nudeceleb Nuderoast nudibranch nudist_loving nudistpornbeach NudistsGoneWild nugswap nujijinactie nukedbywords nukedfromorbit NukeMeFromOrbit NukeVFX nukleus null number26bank numberphile numberwang numerai numerical numerology numismatics numismatology nunavut nunumains NurdRage NurseJackie NurseJoyProject nursepractitioner Nurses nursingmemes nursingschool NursingSkills nus nutanix NutritionFacts NVC nvidiots nwi NWSL nxtcoin NXThemes nxtwrestling nyancoins nyannyancosplay nycART nycbeer NYCC nycfilmmakers nycfood nycgaybros nycgaymers nycHistory nycstreetart nyctech NYCtrees NYguns NYList NYrap nyspolitics nytimes NYTO NYXL nyxnyxnyx NZBitcoin NZCirclejerk nzpolitics NZTrees
submitted by j259awesome to u/j259awesome [link] [comments]

FUD Copy Pastas

**Last updated: May 30, 2018: Updated wallet info with release of Trinity.
This 4 part series from the IOTA foundation covers most of the technical FUD centered at IOTA.
https://blog.iota.org/official-iota-foundation-response-to-the-digital-currency-initiative-at-the-mit-media-lab-part-1-72434583a2
Also the official IOTA faq on iota.org answers nearly all of these questions if you want to hear the answers directly.
Purpose of Writing
Since posting FUD is so ridiculously low-effort in comparison to setting the record straight, I felt it necessary to put a log of copy-pastas together to balance the scales so its just as easy to answer the FUD as it was to generate it. So next time you hear someone say "IOTA is centralized", you no longer have to take an hour out of your day and spin your wheels with someone who likely had an agenda to begin with. You just copy-paste away and move on.
It's also worth mentioning IOTA devs are too damn busy working on the protocol and doing their job to answer FUD. So I felt a semblance of responsibility.
Here they are. These answers are too my understanding so if you see something that doesn't look right let me know! They are divided into the following categories so if you are interested in a specific aspect of IOTA you can scroll to that section.
1) WALLET
2) COMMUNITY
3) INVESTING
4) TECHNICAL

WALLET

IOTA was hacked and users funds were stolen!

First, IOTA was not hacked. The term “hacked” is thrown around way too brazingly nowadays and often used to describe events that weren’t hacks to begin with. Its a symptom of this space growing way too fast creating situations of the blind leading the blind and causing hysteria.
What happened:
Many IOTA users trusted a certain 3rd party website to create their seed for their wallets. This website silently sent copies of all the seeds generated to an email address and waited till it felt it had enough funds, then it took everyones money simultaneously. That was the ”hack”.
https://blog.iota.org/the-secret-to-security-is-secrecy-d32b5b7f25ef
The lesson:
The absolute #1 marketed feature of crypto is that you are your own bank. Of everything that is common knowledge about crypto, this is at the top. But being your own bank means you are responsible for the security of your own funds. There is no safety net or centralized system in place that is going to bail you out.
For those that don’t know (and you really should if you’ve invested in anything crypto), your seed is your username-pw-security question-backup email all rolled into one. Would you trust a no-name 3rd party website to produce your username+pw for your bank account? Because thats essentially what users did.
The fix:
Make your seed offline with the generators in the sidebar or use dice. This is outlined in the “how to generate wallet and seed” directly following.
The trinity and carriota wallets will have seed generators within them upon their release.

How to generate wallet and seed

1) Download official trinity wallet here
2) follow the instructions on the app.
3) Do not run any apps in conjunction with the trinity app. Make sure all other apps are completely closed out on your device.

Are you sure a computer can’t just guess my seed?

An IOTA seed is 81 characters long. There are more IOTA seed combinations than atoms in the universe. All the computers in the world combined would take millions billions of years just to find your randomly generated one that’s located somewhere between the 0th and the 2781st combination. The chance for someone to randomly generate the exact same seed as yours is 1 / (2781).
If you can’t fathom the number 27 ^ 81, this video should help:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p8YIdmwcubc

Why is Trinity wallet taking so long!!??

Trinity is out. https://trinity.iota.org/

COMMUNITY

IOTA introduction video to share with family

https://youtu.be/LyC04NrJ3yA

Tangle visualizers

http://tangle.glumb.de/

How to setup a full node

Download Bolero and run! Bolero is an all-in-one full node install package with the latest IOTA IRI and Nelson all under a one-click install!
https://github.com/SemkoDev/bolero.fun/releases
"If you want to help the network then spam the network. If you really want to help the network then create a full node and let others spam you!"

No questions or concerns get upvoted, only downvoted!

That’s just the nature of this business. Everyone in these communities has money at stake and are extremely incentivized to keep only positive news at the top of the front page. There is nothing you're going to do about that on this subreddit or any crypto subreddit. It's just a reddit fact of life we have to deal with. Everyone has a downvote and everyone has an upvote. But what can be done is just simply answer the questions even if they are downvoted to hell. Yea most people wont' see the answers or discussion but that one person will. every little bit counts.
I will say that there are most certainly answers to nearly every FUD topic out there. Every single one. A lot of the posts I'm seeing as of late especially since the price spike are rehashed from months ago. They are often not answered not because there isn't an answeexplanation, but because regulars who have the answers simply don't see them (for the reason listed above). I can see how it's easy for this to be interpreted (especially by new users) as there not being an answer or "the FUDsters are on to something" but thats just not the case.

Developer's candidness (aka dev's are assholes!)

http://www.reddit.com/Iota/comments/7obyyx/serious_talk_about_pr_system_iota_and_david/ds8ouvc
http://www.reddit.com/Iota/comments/7obyyx/serious_talk_about_pr_system_iota_and_david/ds8rega
http://www.reddit.com/Iota/comments/7oi9g8/why_is_everyone_so_critical_of_david_this_has_to/ds9rtbb
https://i.redd.it/qb0ik4tgny401.jpg
Lastly and to no surprise, David conducts himself very professionally in this interview even when asked several tough questions about the coordinator and MIT criticism.

IOTA Devs do not respond appropriately to criticism

When critiquers provide feedback that is ACTUALLY useful to the devs, then sure they'll be glad to hear it. So far not once has an outside dev brought up something that the IOTA devs found useful. Every single time it ends up being something that was already taken into consideration with the design and if the critiquer did an ounce of research they would know that. Thus you often find the IOTA devs dismissing their opinion as FUD and responding with hostility because all their critique is really doing is sending the message to their supporters that they are not supposed to like IOTA anymore.
Nick Johnson was a perfect example of this. The Ethereum community was co-existing [peacefully]with IOTA’s community (as they do with nearly all alt coins) until Nick wrote his infamous article. Then almost overnight Ethereum decided it didn’t like IOTA anymore and we’ve been dealing with that shit since. As of today, add LTC to that list with Charlie’s (even admitting) ignorant judgement of IOTA.
12/17/2017: Add John McAfee (bitcoin cash) and Peter Todd (bitcoin) to the list of public figures who have posted ignorantly on IOTA.

A lot of crypto communities certainly like to hate on IOTA...

IOTA is disrupting the disrupters. It invented a completely new distributed ledger infrastructure (the tangle) that replaces the blockchain and solves all of its fundamental problems (namely fees and scaling). To give you an idea of this significance, 99% of the cryptocurrencies that exist are built on a block chain. These projects have billions of dollars invested into them meaning everyone in their communities are incentivized to see IOTA fail and spread as much FUD about it as possible. This includes well known organizations, public figures, and brands. Everyone commenting in these subreddits and crypto communities have their own personal money at stake and skin in the game. Misinformation campaigns, paid reddit posters, upvote/downvote bots, and corrupt moderators are all very real in this space.

INVESTING

How do I buy IOTA

https://medium.com/@fuo213/how-to-buy-iota-the-complete-guide-for-crypto-dummies-e63560caf921

What is the IOTA foundation?

IOTA foundation is a non-profit established in Germany and recognized by the European Union. Blog post here: https://blog.iota.org/iota-foundation-fb61937c9a7e

How many companies and organizations are interested, partnered or actively using IOTA?

A lot, and often too many to keep up with.
https://reddit.com/Iota/comments/7f3dmx/list_of_known_iota_partnerships_corporate/

How was IOTA distributed?

All IOTAs that will ever exist were sold at the ICO in 2015. There was no % reserved for development. Devs had to buy in with their personal money. Community donated back 5% of all IOTA so the IOTA foundation could be setup.

No inflation schedule? No additional coins? How is this sustainable?

Interestingly enough, IOTA is actually the only crypto that does not run into any problems with a currency cap and deflationaryism. Because there are zero fees, you will always be able to pay for something for exactly what it's worth using IOTA, no matter how small the value. If by chance in the future a single iota grows so large in value that it no longer allows someone to pay for something in fractions of a penny, the foundation would just add decimal points allowing for a tenth or a hundreth or a thousandth of an iota to be transacted with.
To give you some perspective, if a single IOTA equals 1 penny, IOTA would have a 27 trillion dollar market cap (100x that of Bitcoin's today)

IOTA is not for P2P, only for M2M

With the release of the trinity wallet, it's now dead simple for anyone to use IOTA funds for P2P. Try it out.

Companies technically don’t have to use the IOTA token

Yes they do
Worth clarifying that 0 iota data transactions are perfectly fine and are welcomed since they still provide pow for 2 other transactions and help secure the network. In the early stages, these types of transactions will probably be what give us the tps/pow needed to remove the coordinator and allow the network defend 34% attacks organically.
But... if someone does not want to sell or exchange their data for free (0 IOTA transaction), then Dominic is saying that the IOTA token must be used for that or any exchange in value on the network.
This is inherently healthy for the ecosystem since it provides a neutral and non-profit middle ground that all parties/companies can trust. If one company made their own token it wouldn’t be trusted since companies are incentivized by profits and nothing is stopping them from manipulating their token to make them more money. Thus, the IOTA foundation will not partner with anyone who refuses to take this option off the table.

All these companies are going to influence IOTA development!!

These companies have no influence on the development of IOTA. They either choose to use it or they don’t.

Internet of things is cheap and will stay cheap

Internet of things is one application of IOTA and considered by many to be the 4th industrial revolution. Go do some googling. IOTA having zero fees enables M2M for the first time in history. Also, if a crypto can do M2M it sure as shit can do M2P and P2P. M2M is hard mode.

IOTA surpassing speculation

IOTA, through the data marketplace and [qubic](qubic.iota.org), will be the first crypto to surpass speculation and actually be used in the real world for something. From there, it will branch out into other use cases, such as P2P. Or maybe P2P use of IOTA will grow in parallel with M2M, because why not?
https://blog.iota.org/iota-data-marketplace-cb6be463ac7f
12/19/17 update: Bosch reinforces IOTA's break-out from speculation by buying IOTA tokens for its future use in the data marketplace. https://i.redd.it/8e5b8bi9ov401.png
http://www.bosch-presse.de/pressportal/de/en/robert-bosch-venture-capital-makes-first-investment-in-distributed-ledger-technology-137411.html

Investing in a new project barely off the ground

Investing in a project in its early stages was something typically reserved for wealthy individuals/organizations before ICO’s became a thing. With early investing comes much less hand holding and more responsibility on the user to know what they are doing. If you have a hard time accepting this responsibility, don’t invest and wait for the technology to get easier for you. How many people actually knew how to use and mine bitcoin in 2009 before it had all its gui infrastructure?
IOTA is a tangle, the first of its kind. NOT a copy paste blockchain. As a result wallets and applications for IOTA are the first of their kind and translating the tangle into a nice clean user-friendly blockchain experience for the masses is even more taxing.

Why is the price of my coin falling?!

This may be the most asked question on any crypto subreddit but it's also the easiest to explain. The price typically falls when bad things happen to a coin or media fabricates bad news about a coin and a portion of investors take it seriously. The price increases when good things happen to a coin, such as a new exchange listing or a partnership announced etc.. The one piece that is often forgotten but trumps all these effects is something called "market forces".
Market forces is what happens to your coin when another coin gets a big news hit or a group of other coins get big news hits together. For example, when IOTA data marketplace released, IOTA hit a x5 bull run in a single week. But did you notice all the other alt coins in the red? There are a LOT of traders that are looking at the space as a whole and looking to get in on ANY bull action and will sell their other coins to do so. This effect can also be compounded over a long period of time such as what we witnessed when the bitcoin fork FOMO was going on and alt coins were squeezed continuously to feed it for weeks/months.
These examples really just scratch the surface of market forces but the big takeaway is that your coin or any coin will most certainly fall (or rise) in price at the result of what other coins are doing, with the most well known example being bitcoin’s correlation to every coin on the market. If you don't want to play the market-force game or don't have time for it, then you can never go wrong buying and holding.
It's also important to note that there are layers of investors. There's a top layer of light-stepping investors that are a mixture of day traders and gamblers trying to jump in and jump out to make quick money then look for the next buying (or shorting) opportunity at another coin. There's a middle layer of buyers and holders who did their research, believe in the tech and placing their bets it will win out in the long run. And the bottom layer are the founders and devs that are in it till the bitter end and there to see the vision realized. When a coin goes on a bull run, always expect that any day the top layer is going to pack up and leave to the next coin. But the long game is all about that middle layer. That is the layer that will be giving the bear markets their price-drop resistance. That is why the meme "HODL" is so effective because it very elegantly simplifies this whole concept for the common joe and makes them a part of that middle layer regardless if they understand whats going on or not.

TECHNICAL

How is IOTA free and how does it scale

IOTA is an altruistic system. Proof of work is done in IOTA just like bitcoin. Only a user’s device/phone must do pow for 2 other transactions before issuing one of its own. Therefore no miners and no fees. And the network becomes faster the more transactions are posted. Because of this, spamming the network is encouraged since they provide pow for 2 other transactions and speed up the network.

IOTA is centralized

IOTA is more decentralized than any blockchain crypto that relies on 5 pools of miners, all largely based in China. Furthermore, the coordinator is not a server in the dev’s basement that secretly processes all the transactions. It’s several nodes all around the globe that add milestone transactions to show the direction of the IF’s tangle within the DAG so people don’t accidentally follow a fork from a malicious actor. Anyone with the know-how can fork the tangle right now with a double-spend. But no one would follow their fork because the coordinator reveals which tangle is the legit IF one. If the coordinator wasn’t there (assuming low honest-transaction volume), there would be no way to discern which path to follow especially after the tangle diverges into forks of forks. Once throughout of honest transactions is significant enough, the “honest tangle” will replace the coordinated one and people will know which one to follow simply because it’s the biggest one in the room.
Referencing the coordinator is also optional.
Also, if you research and understand how IOTA intends to work without the coordinator, it’s easier to accept it for now as training wheels. I suggest reading pg 15 and on of the white paper analyzing in great depth how the network will defend different attack scenarios without a coordinator. For the past several months, IOTA foundation has been using St Petersburg college’s super computer to stress test IOTA and learn when they can turn the coordinator off. There will likely be a blog about the results soon.
This is another great read covering double spends on IOTA without a coordinator: www.tangleblog.com/2017/07/10/is-double-spending-possible-with-iota/
This too: http://www.reddit.com/Iota/comments/7eix4a/any_iota_guru_that_can_explain_what_this_guy_is/dq5ijrm
Also this correspondence with Vitalik and Come_from_Beyond https://twitter.com/DavidSonstebo/status/932510087301779456
At the end of the day, outstanding claims require outstanding evidence and folks approaching IOTA with a “I’ll believe it when I see it” attitude is completely understandable. It’s all about your risk tolerance.

Can IOTA defend double spend attacks?

99% of these “but did they think about double spend attacks?” type questions could just be answered if people went and did their own research. Yes of course they thought about that. That’s like crypto101…
www.tangleblog.com/2017/07/10/is-double-spending-possible-with-iota/

Will IOTA have smart contracts?

Yes - qubic.iota.org

Trinary vs binary?

"By using a ternary number system, the amount of devices and cycles can be reduced significantly. In contrast to two-state devices, multistate devices provide better radix economy with the option for further scaling"
https://www.nature.com/articles/srep36652
https://www.reddit.com/CryptoCurrency/comments/6jgbvb/iota_isnt_it_the_perfect_cryptocurrency/dje8os2/

Bitcoin with lightning network will make IOTA obsolete.

If you want lightning network, IOTA already released it. Called flash channels.
https://blog.iota.org/instant-feeless-flash-channels-88572d9a4385

IOTA rolled its own crypto!

https://blog.iota.org/official-iota-foundation-response-to-the-digital-currency-initiative-at-the-mit-media-lab-part-1-72434583a2
This is why: https://blog.iota.org/the-transparency-compendium-26aa5bb8e260
Cybercrypt has been hired to review and audit it. IOTA is currently running SHA-3/KECCAK now until Curl is ready.

MIT said bad things about IOTA

https://blog.iota.org/official-iota-foundation-response-to-the-digital-currency-initiative-at-the-mit-media-lab-part-1-72434583a2
And for official formal closure that MIT was completely wrong:
https://www.reddit.com/CryptoCurrency/comments/7svr8mit_media_lab_dci_allegations_proven_wrong_iotas/
https://blog.iota.org/curl-disclosure-beyond-the-headline-1814048d08ef
https://medium.com/@comefrombeyond/cfbs-comments-on-https-www-media-mit-edu-posts-iota-response-5834c7f8172d

Nick Johnson says IOTA is bad!

Nick Johnson is an ethereum dev who is incentivized to see IOTA fail, see CFBs twitter responses here.
https://mobile.twitter.com/nicksdjohnson/status/912676954184323073?lang=en
And this
https://t.co/1HgfPhg2lP
And this
https://www.reddit.com/Iota/comments/72lly0/comment/dnjk9f5?st=JB2VKUBB&sh=a2892548
And this
https://blog.iota.org/official-iota-foundation-response-to-the-digital-currency-initiative-at-the-mit-media-lab-part-1-72434583a2

IOTA is not private!

Masked authenticated messages exist right now so data can be transferred privately. Very important for businesses.

Coin privacy

Centralized coin mixer is out that foundation runs. Logs are kept so they can collect data and improve it Folks can copy the coin mixer code and run it themselves. Goal is for mixer to be decentralized and ran by any node.

How do nodes scale? How on earth can all that data be stored?

Full nodes store, update and verify from the last snapshot, which happens roughly every month. Its on the roadmap to make snapshotting automatic and up to each full node’s discretion.With automatic snapshots, each full node will act as a partial perma-node and choose when to snapshot its tangle data. If someone wants to keep their tangle data for several months or even years, they could just choose not to snapshot. Or if they are limited on hard drive space, they could snapshot every week.
Perma-nodes would store the entire history of the tangle from the genesis. These are optional and would likely only be created by companies who wish to sell historical access of the tangle as a service or companies who heavily use the tangle for their own data and want to have quick, convenient access to their data’s history.
Swarm nodes are also in development which will ease the burden on full nodes. https://blog.iota.org/iota-development-roadmap-74741f37ed01

Node discovery is manual? Wtf?

Nelson is fixing has fixed this:
https://medium.com/deviota/carriota-nelson-automatic-peer-discovery-for-iota-bdca9b8b8750
https://medium.com/deviota/carriota-nelson-in-a-nutshell-1ee5317d8f19
https://github.com/SemkoDev/nelson.cli

IOTA open source?

https://blog.iota.org/official-iota-foundation-response-to-the-digital-currency-initiative-at-the-mit-media-lab-part-1-72434583a2
IOTA protocol is open source. The coordinator is closed source open source.
https://imgur.com/a/xWQUp

Foundation moved user's funds?

https://blog.iota.org/official-iota-foundation-response-to-the-digital-currency-initiative-at-the-mit-media-lab-part-1-72434583a2
https://blog.iota.org/claims-and-reclaims-finalization-e692844c505a
https://www.reddit.com/Iota/comments/7mmimu/claims_and_reclaims_is_processing/drv63d5/

My IOTA donation address:

9PZFQNPLVDUNGAOYYMMXFWMGNPMNAJWZKTYOOMCYQTZQA9RPVVN9SE9KGOL9HWZFJBXKQGEOY9JJYDXB9TY9FLQPXB
submitted by mufinz2 to Iota [link] [comments]

Long live decentralized bitcoin(!) A reading list

Newbs might not know this, but bitcoin recently came out of an intense internal drama. Between July 2015 and August 2017 bitcoin was attacked by external forces who were hoping to destroy the very properties that made bitcoin valuable in the first place. This culminated in the creation of segwit and the UASF (user activated soft fork) movement. The UASF was successful, segwit was added to bitcoin and with that the anti-decentralization side left bitcoin altogether and created their own altcoin called bcash. Bitcoin's price was $2500, soon after segwit was activated the price doubled to $5000 and continued rising until a top of $20000 before correcting to where we are today.
During this drama, I took time away from writing open source code to help educate and argue on reddit, twitter and other social media. I came up with a reading list for quickly copypasting things. It may be interesting today for newbs or anyone who wants a history lesson on what exactly happened during those two years when bitcoin's very existence as a decentralized low-trust currency was questioned. Now the fight has essentially been won, I try not to comment on reddit that much anymore. There's nothing left to do except wait for Lightning and similar tech to become mature (or better yet, help code it and test it)
In this thread you can learn about block sizes, latency, decentralization, segwit, ASICBOOST, lightning network and all the other issues that were debated endlessly for over two years. So when someone tries to get you to invest in bcash, remind them of the time they supported Bitcoin Unlimited.
For more threads like this see UASF

Summary / The fundamental tradeoff

A trip to the moon requires a rocket with multiple stages by gmaxwell (must read) https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/438hx0/a_trip_to_the_moon_requires_a_rocket_with/
Bram Cohen, creator of bittorrent, argues against a hard fork to a larger block size https://medium.com/@bramcohen/bitcoin-s-ironic-crisis-32226a85e39f#.558vetum4
gmaxwell's summary of the debate https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1343716.msg13701818#msg13701818
Core devs please explain your vision (see luke's post which also argues that blocks are already too big) https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/61yvvv/request_to_core_devs_please_explain_your_vision/
Mod of btc speaking against a hard fork https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/57hd14/core_reaction_to_viabtc_this_week/d8scokm/
It's becoming clear to me that a lot of people don't understand how fragile bitcoin is https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/59kflj/its_becoming_clear_to_me_that_a_lot_of_people/
Blockchain space must be costly, it can never be free https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/4og24h/i_just_attended_the_distributed_trade_conference/
Charlie Lee with a nice analogy about the fundamental tradeoff https://medium.com/@SatoshiLite/eating-the-bitcoin-cake-fc2b4ebfb85e#.444vr8shw
gmaxwell on the tradeoffs https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1520693.msg15303746#msg15303746
jratcliff on the layering https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/59upyh/segwit_the_poison_pill_for_bitcoin/d9bstuw/

Scaling on-chain will destroy bitcoin's decentralization

Peter Todd: How a floating blocksize limit inevitably leads towards centralization [Feb 2013] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=144895.0 mailing list https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2013-February/002176.html with discussion on reddit in Aug 2015 https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/3hnvi8/just_a_little_history_lesson_for_everyone_new_the/
Nick Szabo's blog post on what makes bitcoin so special http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2017/02/money-blockchains-and-social-scalability.html
There is academic research showing that even small (2MB) increases to the blocksize results in drastic node dropoff counts due to the non-linear increase of RAM needed. http://bravenewcoin.com/assets/Whitepapers/block-size-1.1.1.pdf
Reddit summary of above link. In this table, you can see it estimates a 40% drop immediately in node count with a 2MB upgrade and a 50% over 6 months. At 4mb, it becomes 75% immediately and 80% over 6 months. At 8, it becomes 90% and 95%. https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5qw2wa_future_led_by_bitcoin_unlimited_is_a/dd442pw/
Larger block sizes make centralization pressures worse (mathematical) https://petertodd.org/2016/block-publication-incentives-for-miners
Talk at scalingbitcoin montreal, initial blockchain synchronization puts serious constraints on any increase in the block size https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgjrS-BPWDQ&t=2h02m06s with transcript https://scalingbitcoin.org/transcript/montreal2015/block-synchronization-time
Bitcoin's P2P Network: The Soft Underbelly of Bitcoin https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6kibPzbrIc someone's notes: https://gist.github.com/romyilano/5e22394857a39889a1e5 reddit discussion https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/4py5df/so_f2pool_antpool_btcc_pool_are_actually_one_pool/
In adversarial environments blockchains dont scale https://scalingbitcoin.org/transcript/hongkong2015/in-adversarial-environments-blockchains-dont-scale
Why miners will not voluntarily individually produce smaller blocks https://scalingbitcoin.org/transcript/hongkong2015/why-miners-will-not-voluntarily-individually-produce-smaller-blocks
Hal Finney: bitcoin's blockchain can only be a settlement layer (mostly interesting because it's hal finney and its in 2010) https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/3sb5nj/most_bitcoin_transactions_will_occur_between/
petertodd's 2013 video explaining this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZp7UGgBR0I
luke-jr's summary https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/61yvvv/request_to_core_devs_please_explain_your_vision/dficjhj/
Another jratcliff thread https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6lmpll/explaining_why_big_blocks_are_bad/

Full blocks are not a disaster

Blocks must be always full, there must always be a backlog https://medium.com/@bergealex4/bitcoin-is-unstable-without-the-block-size-size-limit-70db07070a54#.kh2vi86lr
Same as above, the mining gap means there must always be a backlog talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=2453&v=iKDC2DpzNbw transcript: https://scalingbitcoin.org/transcript/montreal2015/security-of-diminishing-block-subsidy
Backlogs arent that bad https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/49p011/was_the_fee_event_really_so_bad_my_mind_is/
Examples where scarce block space causes people to use precious resources more efficiently https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/4kxxvj/i_just_singlehandedly_increased_bitcoin_network/
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/47d4m2/why_does_coinbase_make_2_transactions_pe
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/53wucs/why_arent_blocks_full_yet/d7x19iv
Full blocks are fine https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5uld1a/misconception_full_blocks_mean_bitcoin_is_failing/
High miner fees imply a sustainable future for bitcoin https://www.reddit.com/BitcoinMarkets/comments/680tvf/fundamentals_friday_week_of_friday_april_28_2017/dgwmhl7/
gmaxwell on why full blocks are good https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6b57ca/full_blocks_good_or_bad/dhjxwbz/
The whole idea of the mempool being "filled" is wrong headed. The mempool doesn't "clog" or get stuck, or anything like that. https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/7cusnx/to_the_people_still_doubting_that_this_congestion/dpssokf/

Segwit

What is segwit

luke-jr's longer summary https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6033h7/today_is_exactly_4_months_since_the_segwit_voting/df3tgwg/?context=1
Charlie Shrem's on upgrading to segwit https://twitter.com/CharlieShrem/status/842711238853513220
Original segwit talk at scalingbitcoin hong kong + transcript https://youtu.be/zchzn7aPQjI?t=110
https://scalingbitcoin.org/transcript/hongkong2015/segregated-witness-and-its-impact-on-scalability
Segwit is not too complex https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/57vjin/segwit_is_not_great/d8vos33/
Segwit does not make it possible for miners to steal coins, contrary to what some people say https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/5e6bt0/concerns_with_segwit_and_anyone_can_spend/daa5jat/?context=1
https://keepingstock.net/segwit-eli5-misinformation-faq-19908ceacf23#.r8hlzaquz
Segwit is required for a useful lightning network It's now known that without a malleability fix useful indefinite channels are not really possible.
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5tzqtc/gentle_reminder_the_ln_doesnt_require_segwit/ddqgda7/
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5tzqtc/gentle_reminder_the_ln_doesnt_require_segwit/ddqbukj/
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5x2oh0/olaoluwa_osuntokun_all_active_lightning_network/deeto14/?context=3
Clearing up SegWit Lies and Myths: https://achow101.com/2016/04/Segwit-FUD-Clearup
Segwit is bigger blocks https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5pb8vs/misinformation_is_working_54_incorrectly_believe/dcpz3en/
Typical usage results in segwit allowing capacity equivalent to 2mb blocks https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/69i2md/observe_for_yourself_segwit_allows_2_mb_blocks_in/

Why is segwit being blocked

Jihan Wu (head of largest bitcoin mining group) is blocking segwit because of perceived loss of income https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/60mb9e/complete_high_quality_translation_of_jihans/
Witness discount creates aligned incentives https://segwit.org/why-a-discount-factor-of-4-why-not-2-or-8-bbcebe91721e#.h36odthq0 https://medium.com/@SegWit.co/what-is-behind-the-segwit-discount-988f29dc1edf#.sr91dg406
or because he wants his mining enterprise to have control over bitcoin https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6jdyk8/direct_report_of_jihan_wus_real_reason_fo

Segwit is being blocked because it breaks ASICBOOST, a patented optimization used by bitmain ASIC manufacturer

Details and discovery by gmaxwell https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2017-April/013996.html
Reddit thread with discussion https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/63otrp/gregory_maxwell_major_asic_manufacturer_is/
Simplified explaination by jonny1000 https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/64qq5g/attempted_explanation_of_the_alleged_asicboost/
http://www.mit.edu/~jlrubin/public/pdfs/Asicboost.pdf
https://medium.com/@jimmysong/examining-bitmains-claims-about-asicboost-1d61118c678d
Evidence https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/63yo27/some_circumstantial_evidence_supporting_the_claim/
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/63vn5g/please_dont_stop_us_from_using_asicboost_which/dfxmm75/
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/63soe3/reverse_engineering_an_asic_is_a_significant_task/dfx9nc
Bitmain admits their chips have asicboost but they say they never used it on the network (haha a likely story) https://blog.bitmain.com/en/regarding-recent-allegations-smear-campaigns/
Worth $100m per year to them (also in gmaxwell's original email) https://twitter.com/petertoddbtc/status/849798529929424898
Other calculations show less https://medium.com/@vcorem/the-real-savings-from-asicboost-to-bitmaintech-ff265c2d305b
This also blocks all these other cool updates, not just segwit https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/63otrp/gregory_maxwell_major_asic_manufacturer_is/dfw0ej3/
Summary of bad consequences of asicboost https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/64qq5g/attempted_explanation_of_the_alleged_asicboost/dg4hyqk/?context=1
Luke's summary of the entire situation https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6ego3s/why_is_killing_asicboost_not_a_priority/diagkkb/?context=1
Prices goes up because now segwit looks more likely https://twitter.com/TuurDemeestestatus/849846845425799168
Asicboost discovery made the price rise https://twitter.com/TuurDemeestestatus/851520094677200901
A pool was caught red handed doing asicboost, by this time it seemed fairly certain that segwit would get activated so it didnt produce as much interest as earlier https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6p7lr5/1hash_pool_has_mined_2_invalid_blocks/ and https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6p95dl/interesting_1hash_pool_mined_some_invalid_blocks/ and https://twitter.com/petertoddbtc/status/889475196322811904
This btc user is outraged at the entire forum because they support Bitmain and ASICBOOST https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/67t43y/dragons_den_planned_smear_campaign_of_bitmain/dgtg9l2/
Antbleed, turns out Bitmain can shut down all its ASICs by remote control: http://www.antbleed.com/

What if segwit never activates

What if segwit never activates? https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6ab8js/transaction_fees_are_now_making_btc_like_the_banks/dhdq3id/ with https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5ksu3o/blinded_bearer_certificates/ and https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/4xy0fm/scaling_quickly/

Lightning

bitcoinmagazine's series on what lightning is and how it works https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/understanding-the-lightning-network-part-building-a-bidirectional-payment-channel-1464710791/ https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/understanding-the-lightning-network-part-creating-the-network-1465326903/ https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/understanding-the-lightning-network-part-completing-the-puzzle-and-closing-the-channel-1466178980/
The Lightning Network ELIDHDICACS (Explain Like I Don’t Have Degrees in Cryptography and Computer Science) https://letstalkbitcoin.com/blog/post/the-lightning-network-elidhdicacs
Ligtning will increases fees for miners, not lower them https://medium.com/lightning-resources/the-lightning-paradox-f15ce0e8e374#.erfgunumh
Cost-benefit analysis of lightning from the point of view of miners https://medium.com/@rusty_lightning/miners-and-bitcoin-lightning-a133cd550310#.x42rovlg8
Routing blog post by rusty https://medium.com/@rusty_lightning/routing-dijkstra-bellman-ford-and-bfg-7715840f004 and reddit comments https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/4lzkz1/rusty_russell_on_lightning_routing_routing/
Lightning protocol rfc https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lightning-rfc
Blog post with screenshots of ln being used on testnet https://medium.com/@btc_coach/lightning-network-in-action-b18a035c955d video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxGiMu4V7ns
Video of sending and receiving ln on testnet https://twitter.com/alexbosworth/status/844030573131706368
Lightning tradeoffs http://www.coindesk.com/lightning-technical-challenges-bitcoin-scalability/
Beer sold for testnet lightning https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/62uw23/lightning_network_is_working_room77_is_accepting/ and https://twitter.com/MrHodl/status/848265171269283845
Lightning will result in far fewer coins being stored on third parties because it supports instant transactions https://medium.com/@thecryptoconomy/the-barely-discussed-incredible-benefit-of-the-lightning-network-4ce82c75eb58
jgarzik argues strongly against LN, he owns a coin tracking startup https://twitter.com/petertoddbtc/status/860826532650123264 https://twitter.com/Beautyon_/status/886128801926795264
luke's great debunking / answer of some misinformation questions https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6st4eq/questions_about_lightning_network/dlfap0u/
Lightning centralization doesnt happen https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6vzau5/reminder_bitcoins_key_strength_is_in_being/dm4ou3v/?context=1
roasbeef on hubs and charging fees https://twitter.com/roasbeef/status/930209165728825344 and https://twitter.com/roasbeef/status/930210145790976000

Immutability / Being a swiss bank in your pocket / Why doing a hard fork (especially without consensus) is damaging

A downside of hard forks is damaging bitcoin's immutability https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5em6vu/what_happens_if_segwit_doesnt_activate/dae1r6c/?context=3
Interesting analysis of miners incentives and how failure is possible, don't trust the miners for long term https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5gtew4/why_an_increased_block_size_increases_the_cost_of/daybazj/?context=2
waxwing on the meaning of cash and settlement https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5ei7m3/unconfirmed_transactions_60k_total_fees_14btc/dad001v/
maaku on the cash question https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5i5iq5/we_are_spoiled/db5luiv/?context=1
Digital gold funamentalists gain nothing from supporting a hard fork to larger block sizes https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5xzunq/core_please_compromise_before_we_end_up_with_bu/dem73xg/?context=1
Those asking for a compromise don't understand the underlying political forces https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6ef7wb/some_comments_on_the_bip148_uasf_from_the/dia236b/?context=3
Nobody wants a contentious hard fork actually, anti-core people got emotionally manipulated https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5sq5ocontentious_forks_vs_incremental_progress/ddip57o/
The hard work of the core developers has kept bitcoin scalable https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/3hfgpo/an_initiative_to_bring_advanced_privacy_features/cu7mhw8?context=9
Recent PRs to improve bitcoin scaleability ignored by the debate https://twitter.com/jfnewbery/status/883001356168167425
gmaxwell against hard forks since 2013 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=140233.20
maaku: hard forks are really bad https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5zxjza/adam_greg_core_devs_and_big_blockers_now_is_the/df275yk/?context=2

Some metrics on what the market thinks of decentralization and hostile hard forks

The price history shows that the exchange rate drops every time a hard fork threatens: https://i.imgur.com/EVPYLR8.jpg
and this example from 2017 https://twitter.com/WhalePanda/status/845562763820912642
http://imgur.com/a/DuHAn btc users lose money
price supporting theymos' moderation https://i.imgur.com/0jZdF9h.png
old version https://i.imgur.com/BFTxTJl.png
older version https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CxqtUakUQAEmC0d.jpg
about 50% of nodes updated to the soft fork node quite quickly https://imgur.com/O0xboVI

Bitcoin Unlimited / Emergent Consensus is badly designed, changes the game theory of bitcoin

Bitcoin Unlimited was a proposed hard fork client, it was made with the intention to stop segwit from activating
A Future Led by Bitcoin Unlimited is a Centralized Future https://blog.sia.tech/a-future-led-by-bitcoin-unlimited-is-a-centralized-future-e48ab52c817a#.p1ly6hldk
Flexible transactions are bugged https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/57tf5g/bitcoindev_bluematt_on_flexible_transactions/
Bugged BU software mines an invalid block, wasting 13 bitcoins or $12k
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5qwtr2/bitcoincom_loses_132btc_trying_to_fork_the/
https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/5qx18i/bitcoincom_loses_132btc_trying_to_fork_the/
bitcoin.com employees are moderators of btc https://medium.com/@WhalePanda/the-curious-relation-between-bitcoin-com-anti-segwit-propaganda-26c877249976#.vl02566k4
miners don't control stuff like the block size http://hackingdistributed.com/2016/01/03/time-for-bitcoin-user-voice/
even gavin agreed that economic majority controls things https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5ywoi9/in_2010_gavin_predicted_that_exchanges_ie_the/
fork clients are trying to steal bitcoin's brand and network effect, theyre no different from altcoins https://medium.com/@Coinosphere/why-bitcoin-unlimited-should-be-correctly-classified-as-an-attempted-robbery-of-bitcoin-not-a-9355d075763c#.qeaynlx5m
BU being active makes it easier to reverse payments, increases wasted work making the network less secure and giving an advantage to bigger miners https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5g1x84/bitcoin_unlimited_bu_median_value_of_miner_eb/
bitcoin unlimited takes power away from users and gives it to miners https://medium.com/@alpalpalp/bitcoin-unlimiteds-placebo-controls-6320cbc137d4#.q0dv15gd5
bitcoin unlimited's accepted depth https://twitter.com/tdryja/status/804770009272696832
BU's lying propaganda poster https://imgur.com/osrViDE

BU is bugged, poorly-reviewed and crashes

bitcoin unlimited allegedly funded by kraken stolen coins
https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/55ajuh/taint_analysis_on_bitcoin_stolen_from_kraken_on/
https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/559miz/taint_analysis_on_btc_allegedly_stolen_from_kraken/
Other funding stuff
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5zozmn/damning_evidence_on_how_bitcoin_unlimited_pays/
A serious bug in BU https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5h70s3/bitcoin_unlimited_bu_the_developers_have_realized/
A summary of what's wrong with BU: https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5z3wg2/jihanwu_we_will_switch_the_entire_pool_to/devak98/

Bitcoin Unlimited Remote Exploit Crash 14/3/2017

https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5zdkv3/bitcoin_unlimited_remote_exploit_crash/ https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5zeb76/timbe https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/5zdrru/peter_todd_bu_remote_crash_dos_wtf_bug_assert0_in/
BU devs calling it as disaster https://twitter.com/SooMartindale/status/841758265188966401 also btc deleted a thread about the exploit https://i.imgur.com/lVvFRqN.png
Summary of incident https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5zf97j/i_was_undecided_now_im_not/
More than 20 exchanges will list BTU as an altcoin
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5zyg6g/bitcoin_exchanges_unveil_emergency_hard_fork/
Again a few days later https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/60qmkt/bu_is_taking_another_shit_timberrrrr

User Activated Soft Fork (UASF)

site for it, including list of businesses supporting it http://www.uasf.co/
luke's view
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5zsk45/i_am_shaolinfry_author_of_the_recent_usedf1dqen/?context=3
threat of UASF makes the miner fall into line in litecoin
https://www.reddit.com/litecoin/comments/66omhlitecoin_global_roundtable_resolution/dgk2thk/?context=3
UASF delivers the goods for vertcoin
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/692mi3/in_test_case_uasf_results_in_miner_consensus/dh3cm34/?context=1
UASF coin is more valuable https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6cgv44/a_uasf_chain_will_be_profoundly_more_valuable/
All the links together in one place https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6dzpew/hi_its_mkwia_again_maintainer_of_uasfbitcoin_on/
p2sh was a uasf https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/v0.6.0/src/main.cpp#L1281-L1283
jgarzik annoyed at the strict timeline that segwit2x has to follow because of bip148 https://twitter.com/jgarzik/status/886605836902162432
Committed intolerant minority https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6d7dyt/a_plea_for_rational_intolerance_extremism_and/
alp on the game theory of the intolerant minority https://medium.com/@alpalpalp/user-activated-soft-forks-and-the-intolerant-minority-a54e57869f57
The risk of UASF is less than the cost of doing nothing https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6bof7a/were_getting_to_the_point_where_a_the_cost_of_not/
uasf delivered the goods for bitcoin, it forced antpool and others to signal (May 2016) https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/antpool-will-not-run-segwit-without-block-size-increase-hard-fork-1464028753/ "When asked specifically whether Antpool would run SegWit code without a hard fork increase in the block size also included in a release of Bitcoin Core, Wu responded: “No. It is acceptable that the hard fork code is not activated, but it needs to be included in a ‘release’ of Bitcoin Core. I have made it clear about the definition of ‘release,’ which is not ‘public.’”"
Screenshot of peter rizun capitulating https://twitter.com/chris_belcher_/status/905231603991007232

Fighting off 2x HF

https://twitter.com/MrHodl/status/895089909723049984
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6h612o/can_someone_explain_to_me_why_core_wont_endorse/?st=j6ic5n17&sh=cc37ee23
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6smezz/segwit2x_hard_fork_is_completely_useless_its_a/?st=j6ic2aw3&sh=371418dd
https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6sbspv/who_exactly_is_segwit2x_catering_for_now_segwit/?st=j6ic5nic&sh=1f86cadd
https://medium.com/@elliotolds/lesser-known-reasons-to-keep-blocks-small-in-the-words-of-bitcoin-core-developers-44861968185e
b2x is most of all about firing core https://twitter.com/WhalePanda/status/912664487135760384
https://medium.com/@StopAndDecrypt/thats-not-bitcoin-this-is-bitcoin-95f05a6fd6c2

Misinformation / sockpuppets

https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6uqz6k/markets_update_bitcoin_cash_rallies_for_three/dlurbpx/
three year old account, only started posting today https://archive.is/3STjH
Why we should not hard fork after the UASF worked: https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6sl1qf/heres_why_we_should_not_hard_fork_in_a_few_months/

History

Good article that covers virtually all the important history https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/long-road-segwit-how-bitcoins-biggest-protocol-upgrade-became-reality/
Interesting post with some history pre-2015 https://btcmanager.com/the-long-history-of-the-fight-over-scaling-bitcoin/
The core scalabality roadmap + my summary from 3/2017 https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2015-Decembe011865.html my summary https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5xa5fa/the_core_development_scalability_roadmap/
History from summer 2015 https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/5xg7f8/the_origins_of_the_blocksize_debate/
Brief reminders of the ETC situation https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6nvlgo/simple_breakdown_of_bip91_its_simply_the_miners/dkcycrz/
Longer writeup of ethereum's TheDAO bailout fraud https://www.reddit.com/ethereumfraud/comments/6bgvqv/faq_what_exactly_is_the_fraud_in_ethereum/
Point that the bigblocker side is only blocking segwit as a hostage https://www.reddit.com/BitcoinMarkets/comments/5sqhcq/daily_discussion_wednesday_february_08_2017/ddi3ctv/?context=3
jonny1000's recall of the history of bitcoin https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6s34gg/rbtc_spreading_misinformation_in_rbitcoinmarkets/dl9wkfx/

Misc (mostly memes)

libbitcoin's Understanding Bitcoin series (another must read, most of it) https://github.com/libbitcoin/libbitcoin/wiki/Understanding-Bitcoin
github commit where satoshi added the block size limit https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/63859l/github_commit_where_satoshi_added_the_block_size/
hard fork proposals from some core devs https://bitcoinhardforkresearch.github.io/
blockstream hasnt taken over the entire bitcoin core project https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/622bjp/bitcoin_core_blockstream/
blockstream is one of the good guys https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6cttkh/its_happening_blockstream_opens_liquid_sidechain/dhxu4e
Forkers, we're not raising a single byte! Song lyrics by belcher https://gist.github.com/chris-belche7264cd6750a86f8b4a9a
Some stuff here along with that cool photoshopped poster https://medium.com/@jimmysong/bitcoin-realism-or-how-i-learned-to-stop-worrying-and-love-1mb-blocks-c191c35e74cb
Nice graphic https://twitter.com/RNR_0/status/871070843698380800
gmaxwell saying how he is probably responsible for the most privacy tech in bitcoin, while mike hearn screwed up privacy https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/6azyme/hey_bu_wheres_your_testnet/dhiq3xo/?context=6
Fairly cool propaganda poster https://twitter.com/urbanarson/status/880476631583924225
btc tankman https://i.redd.it/gxjqenzpr27z.png https://twitter.com/DanDarkPill/status/853653168151986177
asicboost discovery meme https://twitter.com/allenscottoshi/status/849888189124947971
https://twitter.com/urbanarson/status/882020516521013250
gavin wanted to kill the bitcoin chain https://twitter.com/allenscottoshi/status/849888189124947971
stuff that btc believes https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6ld4a5/serious_is_the_rbtc_and_the_bu_crowd_a_joke_how/djszsqu/
after segwit2x NYA got agreed all the fee pressure disappeared, laurenmt found they were artificial spam https://twitter.com/i/moments/885827802775396352
theymos saying why victory isnt inevitable https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6lmpll/explaining_why_big_blocks_are_bad/djvxv2o/
with ignorant enemies like these its no wonder we won https://bitco.in/forum/threads/gold-collapsing-bitcoin-up.16/page-999 ""So, once segwit2x activates, from that moment on it will require a coordinated fork to avoid the up coming "baked in" HF. ""
a positive effect of bcash, it made blockchain utxo spammers move away from bitcoin https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/76lv0b/cryptograffitiinfo_now_accepts_bitcoin_cash/dof38gw/
summary of craig wright, jihan wu and roger ver's positions https://medium.com/@HjalmarPeters/the-big-blockers-bead6027deb2
Why is bitcoin so strong against attack?!?! (because we're motivated and awesome) https://www.reddit.com/btc/comments/64wo1h/bitcoin_unlimited_is_being_blocked_by_antivirus/dg5n00x/
what happened to #oldjeffgarzik https://www.reddit.com/Bitcoin/comments/6ufv5x/a_reminder_of_some_of_jeff_garziks_greatest/
big blockers fully deserve to lose every last bitcoin they ever had and more https://www.reddit.com/BitcoinMarkets/comments/756nxf/daily_discussion_monday_october_09_2017/do5ihqi/
gavinandresen brainstorming how to kill bitcoin with a 51% in a nasty way https://twitter.com/btcdrak/status/843914877542567937
Roger Ver as bitcoin Judas https://imgur.com/a/Rf1Pi
A bunch of tweets and memes celebrating UASF
https://twitter.com/shaolinfry/status/842457019286188032 | https://twitter.com/SatoshiLite/status/888335092560441345 | https://twitter.com/btcArtGallery/status/887485162925285377 | https://twitter.com/Beautyon_/status/888109901611802624 | https://twitter.com/Excellion/status/889211512966873088 | https://twitter.com/lopp/status/888200452197801984 | https://twitter.com/AlpacaSW/status/886988980524396544 | https://twitter.com/BashCo_/status/877253729531162624 | https://twitter.com/tdryja/status/865212300361379840 | https://twitter.com/Excellion/status/871179040157179904 | https://twitter.com/TraceMayestatus/849856343074902016 | https://twitter.com/TraceMayestatus/841855022640033792 | https://fs.bitcoinmagazine.com/img/images/Screen_Shot_2017-08-18_at_01.36.47.original.png
submitted by belcher_ to Bitcoin [link] [comments]

r/bitcoin recap - November 2017

Hi Bitcoiners!
I’m back with the eleventh monthly Bitcoin news recap.
For those unfamiliar, each day I pick out the most popularelevant/interesting stories in bitcoin and save them. At the end of the month I release them in one batch, to give you a quick (but not necessarily the best), memeless overview of what happened in bitcoin over the past month.
You can find recaps of the previous months on Bitcoinsnippets.com
A recap of Bitcoin in November 2017
submitted by SamWouters to Bitcoin [link] [comments]

The Astounding Incompetence, Negligence, and Dishonesty of the Bitcoin Unlimited Developers

On August 26, 2016 someone noticed that their Classic node had been forked off of the "Big Blocks Testnet" that Bitcoin Classic and Bitcoin Unlimited were running. Neither implementation was testing their consensus code on any other testnets; this was effectively the only testnet being used to test either codebase. The issue was due to a block on the testnet that was mined on July 30, almost a full month prior to anyone noticing the fork at all, which was in violation of the BIP109 specification that Classic miners were purportedly adhering to at the time. Gregory Maxwell observed:
That was a month ago, but it's only being noticed now. I guess this is demonstrating that you are releasing Bitcoin Classic without much testing and that almost no one else is either? :-/
The transaction in question doesn't look at all unusual, other than being large. It was, incidentally, mined by pool.bitcoin.com, which was signaling support for BIP109 in the same block it mined that BIP 109 violating transaction.
Later that day, Maxwell asked Roger Ver to clarify whether he was actually running Bitcoin Classic on the bitcoin.com mining pool, who dodged the question and responded with a vacuous reply that attempted to inexplicably change the subject to "censorship" instead.
Andrew Stone (the lead developer of Bitcoin Unlimited) voiced confusion about BIP109 and how Bitcoin Unlimited violated the specification for it (while falsely signaling support for it). He later argued that Bitcoin Unlimited didn't need to bother adhering to specifications that it signaled support for, and that doing so would violate the philosophy of the implementation. Peter Rizun shared this view. Neither developer was able to answer Maxwell's direct question about the violation of BIP109 §4/5, which had resulted in the consensus divergence (fork).
Despite Maxwell having provided a direct link to the transaction violating BIP109 that caused the chain split, and explaining in detail what the results of this were, later Andrew Stone said:
I haven't even bothered to find out the exact cause. We have had BUIP016 passed to adhere to strict BIP109 compatibility (at least in what we generate) by merging Classic code, but BIP109 is DOA -- so no-one bothered to do it.
I think that the only value to be had from this episode is to realise that consensus rules should be kept to an absolute, money-function-protecting minimum. If this was on mainnet, I'll be the Classic users would be unhappy to be forked onto a minority branch because of some arbitrary limit that is yet another thing would have needed to be fought over as machine performance improves but the limit stays the same.
Incredibly, when a confused user expressed disbelief regarding the fork, Andrew Stone responded:
Really? There was no classic fork? As i said i didnt bother to investigate. Can you give me a link to more info? Its important to combat this fud.
Of course, the proof of the fork (and the BIP109-violating block/transaction) had already been provided to Stone by Maxwell. Andrew Stone was willing to believe that the entire fork was imaginary, in the face of verifiable proof of the incident. He admits that he didn't investigate the subject at all, even though that was the only testnet that Unlimited could have possibly been performing any meaningful tests on at the time, and even though this fork forced Classic to abandon BIP109 entirely, leaving it vulnerable to the types of attacks that Gavin Andresen described in his Guided Tour of the 2mb Fork:
“Accurate sigop/sighash accounting and limits” is important, because without it, increasing the block size limit might be dangerous... It is set to 1.3 gigabytes, which is big enough so none of the blocks currently in the block chain would hit it, but small enough to make it impossible to create poison blocks that take minutes to validate.
As a result of this fork (which Stone was clueless enough to doubt had even happened), Bitcoin Classic and Bitcoin Unlimited were both left vulnerable to such attacks. Fascinatingly, this fact did not seem to bother the developers of Bitcoin Unlimited at all.
On November 17, 2016 Andrew Stone decided to post an article titled A Short Tour of Bitcoin Core wherein he claimed:
Bitcoin Unlimited is building the highest quality, most stable, Bitcoin client available. We have a strong commitment to quality and testing as you will see in the rest of this document.
The irony of this claim should soon become very apparent.
In the rest of the article, Stone wrote with venomous and overtly hostile rhetoric:
As we mine the garbage in the Bitcoin Core code together... I want you to realise that these issues are systemic to Core
He went on to describe what he believed to be multiple bugs that had gone unnoticed by the Core developers, and concluded his article with the following paragraph:
I hope when reading these issues, you will realise that the Bitcoin Unlimited team might actually be the most careful committers and testers, with a very broad and dedicated test infrastructure. And I hope that you will see these Bitcoin Core commits— bugs that are not tricky and esoteric, but simple issues that well known to average software engineers —and commits of “Very Ugly Hack” code that do not reflect the care required for an important financial network. I hope that you will realise that, contrary to statements from Adam Back and others, the Core team does not have unique skills and abilities that qualify them to administer this network.
As soon as the article was published, it was immediately and thoroughly debunked. The "bugs" didn't exist in the current Core codebase; some were results of how Andrew had "mucked with wallet code enough to break" it, and "many of issues were actually caused by changes they made to code they didn't understand", or had been fixed years ago in Core, and thus only affected obsolete clients (ironically including Bitcoin Unlimited itself).
As Gregory Maxwell said:
Perhaps the biggest and most concerning danger here isn't that they don't know what they're doing-- but that they don't know what they don't know... to the point where this is their best attempt at criticism.
Amusingly enough, in the "Let's Lose Some Money" section of the article, Stone disparages an unnamed developer for leaving poor comments in a portion of the code, unwittingly making fun of Satoshi himself in the process.
To summarize: Stone set out to criticize the Core developer team, and in the process revealed that he did not understand the codebase he was working on, had in fact personally introduced the majority of the bugs that he was criticizing, and was actually completely unable to identify any bugs that existed in current versions Core. Worst of all, even after receiving feedback on his article, he did not appear to comprehend (much less appreciate) any of these facts.
On January 27, 2017, Bitcoin Unlimited excitedly released v1.0 of their software, announcing:
The third official BU client release reflects our opinion that Bitcoin full-node software has reached a milestone of functionality, stability and scalability. Hence, completion of the alpha/beta phase throughout 2009-16 can be marked in our release version.
A mere 2 days later, on January 29, their code accidentally attempted to hard-fork the network. Despite there being a very clear and straightforward comment in Bitcoin Core explaining the space reservation for coinbase transactions in the code, Bitcoin Unlimited obliviously merged a bug into their client which resulted in an invalid block (23 bytes larger than 1MB) being mined by Roger Ver's Bitcoin.com mining pool on January 29, 2017, costing the pool a minimum of 13.2 bitcoins. A large portion of Bitcoin Unlimited nodes and miners (which naively accepted this block as valid) were temporarily banned from the network as a result, as well.
The code change in question revealed that the Bitcoin Unlimited developers were not only "commenting out and replacing code without understanding what it's for" as well as bypassing multiple safety-checks that should have prevented such issues from occurring, but that they were not performing any peer review or testing whatsoever of many of the code changes they were making. This particular bug was pushed directly to the master branch of Bitcoin Unlimited (by Andrew Stone), without any associated pull requests to handle the merge or any reviewers involved to double-check the update. This once again exposed the unprofessionalism and negligence of the development team and process of Bitcoin Unlimited, and in this case, irrefutably had a negative effect in the real world by costing Bitcoin.com thousands of dollars worth of coins.
In effect, this was the first public mainnet fork attempt by Bitcoin Unlimited. Unsurprisingly, the attempt failed, costing the would-be forkers real bitcoins as a result. It is possible that the costs of this bug are much larger than the lost rewards and fees from this block alone, as other Bitcoin Unlimited miners may have been expending hash power in the effort to mine slightly-oversized (invalid) blocks prior to this incident, inadvertently wasting resources in the doomed pursuit of invalid coins.
On March 14, 2017, a remote exploit vulnerability discovered in Bitcoin Unlimited crashed 75% of the BU nodes on the network in a matter of minutes.
In order to downplay the incident, Andrew Stone rapidly published an article which attempted to imply that the remote-exploit bug also affected Core nodes by claiming that:
approximately 5% of the “Satoshi” Bitcoin clients (Core, Unlimited, XT) temporarily dropped off of the network
In reddit comments, he lied even more explicitly, describing it as "a bug whose effects you can see as approximate 5% drop in Core node counts" as well as a "network-wide Bitcoin client failure". He went so far as to claim:
the Bitcoin Unlimited team found the issue, identified it as an attack and fixed the problem before the Core team chose to ignore it
The vulnerability in question was in thinblock.cpp, which has never been part of Bitcoin Core; in other words, this vulnerability only affected Bitcoin Classic and Bitcoin Unlimited nodes.
In the same Medium article, Andrew Stone appears to have doctored images to further deceive readers. In the reddit thread discussing this deception, Andrew Stone denied that he had maliciously edited the images in question, but when questioned in-depth on the subject, he resorted to citing his own doctored images as sources and refused to respond to further requests for clarification or replication steps.
Beyond that, the same incident report (and images) conspicuously omitted the fact that the alleged "5% drop" on the screenshotted (and photoshopped) node-graph was actually due to the node crawler having been rebooted, rather than any problems with Core nodes. This fact was plainly displayed on the 21 website that the graph originated from, but no mention of it was made in Stone's article or report, even after he was made aware of it and asked to revise or retract his deceptive statements.
There were actually 3 (fundamentally identical) Xthin-assert exploits that Unlimited developers unwittingly publicized during this episode, which caused problems for Bitcoin Classic, which was also vulnerable.
On top of all of the above, the vulnerable code in question had gone unnoticed for 10 months, and despite the Unlimited developers (including Andrew Stone) claiming to have (eventually) discovered the bug themselves, it later came out that this was another lie; an external security researcher had actually discovered it and disclosed it privately to them. This researcher provided the following quotes regarding Bitcoin Unlimited:
I am quite beside myself at how a project that aims to power a $20 billion network can make beginner’s mistakes like this.
I am rather dismayed at the poor level of code quality in Bitcoin Unlimited and I suspect there [is] a raft of other issues
The problem is, the bugs are so glaringly obvious that when fixing it, it will be easy to notice for anyone watching their development process,
it doesn’t help if the software project is not discreet about fixing critical issues like this.
In this case, the vulnerabilities are so glaringly obvious, it is clear no one has audited their code because these stick out like a sore thumb
In what appeared to be a desperate attempt to distract from the fundamental ineptitude that this vulnerability exposed, Bitcoin Unlimited supporters (including Andrew Stone himself) attempted to change the focus to a tweet that Peter Todd made about the vulnerability, blaming him for exposing it and prompting attackers to exploit it... but other Unlimited developers revealed that the attacks had actually begun well before Todd had tweeted about the vulnerability. This was pointed out many times, even by Todd himself, but Stone ignored these facts a week later, and shamelessly lied about the timeline in a propagandistic effort at distraction and misdirection.
submitted by sound8bits to Bitcoin [link] [comments]

Crypto Mining Pool Server Setup Vlog #3 Noobs Guide to Mining BCD Bitcoin Diamond A look inside America's largest Bitcoin mining operation ... WTF Happened to BITCOIN?! - YouTube Bitcoin Mining Sucks  Why?  Demystifying Bitcoin Mining Rigs, Pools & Shares

Bitcoin mining is the process of creating new bitcoin by solving a computational puzzle. Bitcoin mining is necessary to maintain the ledger of transactions upon which bitcoin is based. Bitcoin is a distributed, worldwide, decentralized digital money. Bitcoins are issued and managed without any central authority whatsoever: there is no government, company, or bank in charge of Bitcoin. You might be interested in Bitcoin if you like cryptography, distributed peer-to-peer systems, or economics. A large percentage of Bitcoin enthusiasts are libertarians, though people of all ... Multicurrency mining pool with easy-to-use GUI miner. Ethereum, Zcash, Monero & other altcoins. Join our vibrant community of more than a million clients. Start mining effectively with your computer or smartphone. Squeeze the most profit automining coins with the highest rates. Downloads. Mining Pools. Monero XMR Grin GRIN Bitcoin BTC Ethereum ETH Litecoin LTC Ethereum Classic ETC Bitcoin Gold ... The first thing we need is a mining pool. You can solo mine, but the payouts could take months depending on how powerful your mining rig is, and the mining pools usually charge a very small fee (1% or less). Using a pool will allow you to receive consistent payouts, multiple times per day. The bitcoin private team has an official list of most of the mining pools Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. get reddit premium. btc subscribe unsubscribe 251,924 ...

[index] [16301] [3426] [17084] [16766] [24704] [7428] [23139] [29882] [40076] [51072]

Crypto Mining Pool Server Setup Vlog #3

Start mining Bitcoin today: https://pool.bitcoin.com Video: Inside America’s largest Bitcoin mining operation http://bitshare.cm/news/inside-americas-largest... Bitcoin Mine Earn Bitcoins With best Bitcoin MIning Games! Free BTC! Link : https://bit.ly/2qyIvLd 5 Steps To Building A Profitable Home Internet Business In 2017 Link Of The Article : https://goo ... Bitcoin & Cryptocurrency - Monthly Mining Update In this new monthly mining segment we will be diving in to all the latest from the Bitcoin & cryptocurrency mining industry. What hash rate is ... white-crypto.com, free bitcoin mining sites without investment 2020, freebitcoin 2020, legit bitcoin mining sites 2020. site link https://zee.gl/fQaJn top hi... bitcoin mining software - best free bitcoin mining software pro. This is Bitcoin Mining Software 2020 BEST Bitcoin Miner How I became a Millionaire Thanks to...

#